"Jazz is the ocean... Ns am just one wave developing one curl, crashing as soon as onto part remote beach somewhere in time. And also that wave makes a tiny imperceptible adjust in the steep of the sand, top top which in ~ some point in time a baby turtle will certainly walk across, leaving his trace for just an instant, prior to the birds washes it clean. That"s a nice cool analogy. Much more to the point, I execute not beat piano and also I do this jazz album." these words from Jon Benjamin speak at as soon as so much and so little about what"s keep going on his baffling record, Well I should have..., reflecting on the one hand his penchant because that humorous contradictions, while on the various other neglecting to take the implications of those conflict seriously. The the punchline of the album"s title is "learned to play the piano" will come as no surprise to anyone who tolerates his take it on—or is it a leaving of?—"It had actually to it is in You," in which his fingers dance uncertainly around the evergreen. In fraying the edge of one otherwise crisp rendering thereof by saxophonist

You are watching: Well, i should have...

" data-original-title="" title="">David Finck on bass, Jonathon Peretz top top drums, and the above-mentioned Kreitzer ~ above sax, all three of whom are far braver for stepping into the studio with Benjamin 보다 he with them. One deserve to only feel for the bona fide jazzmen, who supposedly walked right into this job unknowing of its conceit. Every the an ext appropriate the Benjamin should likewise have appeared on Dr. Katz, since after listening come this album you could just need a therapy session to acquire it out of her system. Then again, it"s just fair come assert: this isn"t a jazz album, every se, but a comedy album, together made painfully clean by the spoken-word bits that structure it and, simply barely, host it up in the middle. "Deal v the Devil" find Benjamin meeting with the Red male himself to market his soul, so that he might attain the mastery compelled to pull turn off making the document he for this reason naively envisions. Yet even the adversary assures the that marketing one"s heart for such a purpose have to be a critical resort fairly than a very first step. A cautionary tale, perhaps, however one that fails to monitor through, for rather than offering his soul, Benjamin has actually robbed the music of its own. The break up "Amy"s tune (The Bum Steer)," a crude laboratory missive around anal intercourse, is every you should know about where the set list is ultimately heading. However the album"s center—a four-part suite, if girlfriend will, licensed has been granted "I Can"t beat Piano" and also built on what that admitted in one NPR interview as his "real untapped un-talent"—is more than likely the key reason why you"ve stuck to my review this far, so let"s acquire to the music. One thing is obvious: Benjamin has acquired a standup band at his disposal. The rhythm ar of Finck and also Peretz is in the bag from the begin of part 1 and also sells the emotion of a legit jazz recording, i beg your pardon Benjamin deserve to only veneer v his posturing. His pianism is amusing and erratic, amounting come little much more than dribbling without ever making a basket. One certainly can"t deny a certain energy and also feel because that rhythm, however the timing gets shed in the chasm the his indulgence. There"s other astonishingly surreal around it all, as if this album shouldn"t exist in a civilization such as ours. However it does, and also its confrontational stance is, if anything, something come regard. In component 2 the band swings with panache, also as Benjamin stumbles, trips, and also falls face-first into a steaming pile of failure. Single notes fare far better than the random block chords, i m sorry come across as full-fisted bleats (Yoko Ono walk it far better). What"s fascinating to an alert here is how self-conscious Benjamin unexpectedly becomes. It"s appropriate there in his solos, which now feel an ext like padding than filler. He avoids the facility as if in fear of what can come that it, commerce his abandon for trepidation. One deserve to actually feel him realizing just exactly how deeply the is the end of his league. Possibly this is why, in the Latin-flavored component 4, he hogs so lot of the earlier seat and makes really attempts at harmony, even if any flickers of expect are easily snuffed together he throws open up the home window to take in the full view of his avowed un-talent. Finck and also Kreitzer take it this opportunity to grab part much-deserved spotlight, both sounding together if lock were playing in a different studio altogether. Castle might too be. But it"s in part 3 where the implications of Benjamin"s precarious enterprise end up being too an overwhelming to ignore. In it, he hardly echoes the thematic setup from Kreitzer, that draws Peretz into some tight drumming, Benjamin struggling every the while against the tide of experience to say anything worth hearing. What separates him, then, indigenous the specialists is the he doesn"t translate any type of of his neighboring impulses right into a an individual language. Instead, his personality is confined to utterances that die the minute he produce them. On this track, the engages Kreitzer in the just exchange that elicited laughter from me, together he hurls bon mots prefer "Take this!" or "You have the right to do better!" in ~ the saxophonist, who competency is already beyond proven. It to be at this allude in mine listening that everything amusement might have been rattling in my head turned right into sober reflection, for only then go it occur to me what Benjamin was failing to embrace: collaboration, without which jazz is nothing. Ns imagine friend will discover yourself, assuming you deserve to sit v the entire album, emotion so rejuvenated at any time Benjamin cuts out come let the main point trio take the helm the your appreciation because that the level of skill that goes right into this beloved art form will be heightened. One require hardly hear to Well I must have... to obtain this effect, yet it"s the just conclusion I deserve to safely with within its confines. The stakes are so low below that it"s hardly worth criticizing Benjamin"s motivations together a satirist. There are plenty of thoughtful jazz parodies the end there. Take Whiplash, because that instance—which, despite brilliant, is anything however a film about music. If something positive deserve to be understood from this, it"s that, in his beguiling way, Benjamin has, by doing therefore little, affirmed all that is great and true in jazz native those who perform so much.

See more: Good Shepherd Lutheran Church Of The Good Shepherd Watertown

His i can not qualify to listen what his bandmates room doing, absence of cooperation impulse, and nonexistent investment in the genre display just just how committedly the completed musician must embody those really things...and so much more.